BLOOMFIELD HILLS, MI - Individuals charged with Operating While Intoxicated in Michigan face critical decisions about legal representation that can significantly impact case outcomes. Oakland County OWI defense attorney Paul J. Tafelski of Michigan Defense Law (https://www.michigandefenselaw.com/blog/dui-public-defender-vs-private-attorney/) explains the key differences between court-appointed public defenders and private counsel for those facing drunk driving charges.
According to Oakland County OWI defense attorney Paul J. Tafelski, Michigan's public defender system operates as a county-by-county patchwork rather than a unified statewide structure. While some defendants receive adequate representation, the National Legal Aid & Defender Association found in 2008 that none of the public defender services in sample Michigan counties were constitutionally adequate. "The problem is not the skill or dedication of public defenders, but rather the systemic constraints they face," explains Tafelski.
Oakland County OWI defense attorney Paul J. Tafelski emphasizes that budget and caseload limitations directly affect case preparation. Public defenders often lack the resources to retain expert witnesses to challenge breath-test results or review equipment maintenance records. Time constraints may prevent comprehensive investigations into whether law enforcement had legal justification for the traffic stop or administered tests properly.
Attorney Tafelski notes that many OWI defendants mistakenly believe they have no case if they registered over the legal limit on a breath test. "An investigation can reveal that law enforcement lacked legal justification to stop your vehicle, administered the test improperly, used faulty equipment, or obtained a false positive reading," he adds. Private attorneys have the resources to retain experts who can challenge chemical test results and thoroughly review police procedures.
The firm notes that public defenders are not free, despite common misconceptions. Courts charge fees for appointed counsel services, and defendants must be found indigent or partially indigent to qualify. Beyond court fees, an OWI conviction carries statutory penalties including fines up to $500 for first offenses, potential jail time up to 93 days, community service requirements, and license suspension up to 180 days.
Tafelski advises that the consequences of conviction extend far beyond statutory penalties. Professional licensing, employment opportunities, insurance rates, and college admissions can all be affected by an OWI on one's record. Driver's license restoration is handled through the Michigan Secretary of State's administrative hearing process, and court-appointed counsel typically does not include representation for administrative licensing matters.
"Many clients reach a point where they would give anything to go back and hire the strongest possible defense from the beginning," observes Tafelski. "By then, the conviction is on their record, and the damage is done." Early representation allows attorneys to attend the arraignment, request immediate discovery, and conduct investigations. At the same time, the evidence is fresh, file motions to suppress illegally obtained evidence, and communicate with prosecutors early to explore favorable resolutions.
Bureau of Justice Statistics data show similar conviction rates for defendants with court-appointed and retained counsel. However, meaningful differences appear in pretrial release rates and sentencing patterns. The high demand for public defenders, combined with limited government fundin,g means court-appointed attorneys often carry caseloads that prevent regular client meetings or thorough case preparation.
Private attorneys in Oakland County district courts benefit from knowing local prosecutors, understanding court procedures, and maintaining established relationships that can benefit clients during plea negotiations. At the 48th District Court in Bloomfield Hills or the Oakland County Circuit Court in Pontiac, thorough preparation can make the difference between conviction and acquittal.
For those facing OWI charges in Michigan, contacting an experienced defense attorney early in the process may help protect driving privileges, employment, and freedom. Defendants can switch from a public defender to private counsel at any point before case conclusion by filing a motion to substitute counsel with the court.
About Michigan Defense Law:
Michigan Defense Law is a Bloomfield Hills-based law firm dedicated to criminal defense with a focus on OWI and drunk driving cases. Led by attorney Paul J. Tafelski, the firm represents clients throughout Oakland County, including Troy, Birmingham, Southfield, Novi, and surrounding communities. For consultations, call (248) 451-2200.
Embeds:
Youtube Video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zUTmQVRJ14Q
GMB: https://www.google.com/maps?cid=7441820969606749572
Email and website
Email: paul@michigandefenselaw.com
Website: https://www.michigandefenselaw.com/
Media Contact
Company Name: Michigan Defense Law
Contact Person: Paul J. Tafelski
Email: Send Email
Phone: (248) 451-2200
Address:2525 S Telegraph Rd suite 100
City: Bloomfield Hills
State: Michigan 48302
Country: United States
Website: https://www.michigandefenselaw.com/
